I picked up my 6MT cayman T last week; and now with 300 miles on it and still keeping to 4K or lower in RPM can say without question it is an awesome car for street driving. It's fast, and with the PSE sounds great (disable the soundaktor though...that sounds like crap). With that said, if I could spec a 4.0 the same way (e.g. get an allocation before 2023 delivery) and could afford it then I'd probably go with it. I would not go with the S; have driven a 6MT compared to the base and while it's quicker, not a big deal for normal driving but to each their own. So, bottom line, go with what you can afford; they are all terrific. If you're after the greatest of them all.....718 Spyder .