We traded our 2016 M235xi convertible for the 2017 Boxster 718S and have never looked back! Could not be more thrilled with every aspect of the 718S. The BMW was a wonderful car to drive, fun to drive, quick, lots of power, nice ride, but once you drive the 718S you realize quickly that Porsche got it right!! Again, the BMW was sweet, but not in the same league with our new 718S...we couldn't be happier with it. The only "other" would be the amount of wind entering the cabin with the top down, the BMW windscreen did in fact do a little better job at speeds above 50-55 MPH keeping the wind noise/turbulence out...but such a small price to pay for all the other positives...besides you can wear a ball cap and its unnoticeable.
2017 Macan GTS (Carmine Red)
2017 Boxster 718S (Jet Black)