There are as many opinions about using, not using N Spec tyres as there are about how to break in an engine. I probably am fortunate as my Porsche dealer is competitive with Tire Rack pricing so I stick with N Spec.But if there is no issue for warranty in the U.S. go for it.
Definitely fortunate. My dealer is nowhere near competitive ...
... so I just had new Tire Rack-sourced, non N-spec rubber put on my 718 by an indie that happened to have the following in its garage:
- Two 1970s 911 Turbos
- Two 1960s 911 Targas
- 968
- 928
- Three 356s
- A late-model Bentley
- A restored 1980s Rolls Royce
- Several hopped-up BMWs, Mercs
and the gem:
- V-12 Jaguar E-Type with original paint, wheels, and trim
(Yes, this indie knows what it's doing.)
... and all that's beside the fact that what are regarded as the two best tires in the Max Performance Summer category (Michelin MSPS, Continental EC Sport) aren't available as N-spec in the 19-inch and (I believe) 18-inch diameters.
Antitrust laws prevent Porsche from requiring N-spec rubber on its cars. The warranty issues are its way to do its best to circumvent that, and that's why load rating has become the determinant. As I understand it, that was mandated by law in a case that involved another manufacturer.
This has been mentioned before: N spec is an elixir that has snake oil as its biggest ingredient. The only verified difference I've been able to dig up are slight tread adjustments to increase wet-weather traction, primarily done for home-market Autobahn safety. So unless you plan to do triple-digit speeds on wet pavement regularly, I wouldn't sweat N spec.